
Christina Pirello and Susan Levin have answered some of your very important questions about vegan pregnancy. These are the most common questions I received from you Kind Lifers when I first asked January of 2010. There's a lot of great information below, so take a look at it and keep those questions coming! I'll be posting more answers to your questions in parts 2 & 3!
What kind of formula should a vegan baby drink?
Christina: Well, first, I have to say that the best food for babies is breast milk. In the rare instance that a mother cannot nurse, then a formula can be used. There is a lot of controversy around soy and the isoflavones that include phytoestrogen. Somehow, it has been put out there that phytoestrogens are the same as estrogen - but they're not at all the same. Unlike estrogen, phytoestrogens are plant-based. They just behave in the same manner as estrogen receptor cells, which regulate levels of estrogen in a woman's body. That said, the soy formula I have found to be the most natural - without simple sugars, additives, GMOs, antiobiotics or other questionable ingredients - is Baby's Only Organic sweetened with brown rice syrup.
Susan: Soy-based formulas are the best option for a non-breast feeding baby. Human breast milk is unique and not mimicked by anything else in nature, so grocery-store brands of soy, rice, cow's milk by themselves are not substitutes for formula.
Also, macrobiotic counselor, Warren Kramer recommends checking out this book about organic baby food.
Is soy bad for a pregnancy, and while breastfeeding?
Christina: No. Even if a baby is shown to be sensitive to soy, nothing seems to come through in the mother's milk, so there is no worry. While the baby gets all the nutrients the mother consumers, experts say that if a baby has food sensitivities, that does not mean the mother can not enjoy the foods the baby is sensitive to. The baby gets the nutrients, but usually does not show signs of distress from the sensitivity. And, usually, an infant's sensitivity to soy is not something they are born with; often the mother has one, too. We say that the mom should eat normally and see if there is a negative reaction in her infant, like excessive fussiness, indigestion, crying...it will not usually be severe. In fact, studies have shown that mothers eating traditionally-produced organic soy, like tofu, tempeh, shoyu and miso, are more relaxed and as a result, so are the babies.
Susan: Soy products are safe and may even have health advantages. In fact, research has shown that the earlier people consume soy in life, the greater the health advantages. So sharing your love of soy with your children may be a priceless gift. Soy is not essential, but it does reduce cancer risk later in life. Additionally, protein needs go up during pregnancy and lactation, and soy is a great high-protein source. Emphasize whole soy foods such as miso, tempeh, tofu, soy milk, and of course the whole soy bean (edamame).
Christina: People are freaked out by soy because they have been told to be freaked out. The truth is that traditional soy can help women with so many things, from PMS to hot flashes associated with menopause; to reducing breast cancer risk; to reducing muscle tension in the legs. On the other hand, any soy products with soy isolates or isolanted soy protein should be avoided, because the way they're processed makes them unhealthy.
Are soy formulas safe? If so, which one should a mother feed her baby?
Christina: Most soy formulas are loaded with sugar and are not made from organic soybeans, so you could be getting GMOs, pesticides, herbicides, antibiotics and other additives. Again, the only one I have found to be free of all that jazz is Baby's Only Organic.
Susan: Yes, soy formulas are safe. According to published research, there does not seem to be any difference in outcome between babies who drank soy and cow's milk formulas. Dr. Spock himself felt soy formula did have advantages over cow's milk formula because of cow milk's link to various diseases such as type 1 diabetes, lactose intolerance, and dairy allergies.
In the 8th Edition of Dr. Spock's Baby and Child Care, it states, cow's milk itself is not safe for infants. The protein and sugar mix is wrong, and infants fed straight cow's milk are likely to become seriously ill.
How can a vegan, pregnant woman increase her protein without going overboard on soy?
Susan: Don't sweat the protein issue. If you consume adequate calories, your protein needs will be met. When you eat more calories during pregnancy, you naturally consume more protein as well. It takes care of itself! Remember, protein is found in whole grains, beans, peas, nuts, seeds, and vegetables. Yes, even broccoli gets 1/3 of its calories from protein!
Christina: There is no need to go crazy with protein because you're pregnant. There is protein in everything we eat, except fruit. Women should get their protein from beans, soy foods (traditional, again, no isolated soy), seitan and grains like quinoa and amaranth, which contain the same levels of protein and structure as an egg, and a daily serving of nuts. A vegan woman need not go nuts with soy to get what she needs. I usually recommend people eat tofu once a week and enjoy fermented soy more often: twice a week for tempeh, daily for miso. Fermented soy is easy on digestion, so people have fewer difficulties with it.
That covers your soy questions! In parts two and three, we'll look at your questions about breastfeeding, stretch marks, Vitamin B-12 and much more!
12 comments
-
I'd be concerned about the brown rice syrup in the soy formula they are promoting... now that it's shown to have arsenic in it. And the whole article doesn't seem to be backed up by facts. I'd like to see some non-biased articles on soy like a previous poster suggested as well!
-
I'm a little worried by the statement about it being OK to eat things your child is sensitive to while breastfeeding. A few years ago a cousin of mine had grainy stool, and the doctor told my aunt to stop consuming dairy because it was affecting him through her breast milk! Sure enough, she stopped consuming all dairy and his stool returned to normal. Also, to those people who are chastising others for believing that too much soy could be harmful, you're as much a victim of advertisments and propaganda as anyone! I lived in China and I can assure you that Asian people do not eat nearly as much soy as the soy industry claims. They rely mostly on fresh vegetables, fruit, rice, and tea; meat, tofu, and anything with added sugar are traditionally only eaten occassionally. Soy milk is served for breakfast, but generally isn't found after that. Soy sauce is used in cooking but is not a table condiment as it is here. It is an extremely healthy diet and it makes you feel amazing, but soy really isn't as common as people in the West are led to believe. With that said, I'm pregnant myself and I appreciate any advice on how to maintain a healthy diet from now through breastfeeding, but I will be careful about eating ANYTHING processed, including soy, no matter how safe it may (or may not) be.
-
I juiced all diferent types of fruit and vegetable while my wife was pregnant with our son and she drank them.. and after he was born, i continued to feed him fresh carrot, celery, beet, spinach juice ect... in every meal,,, he is now a big 25 year old vegan 250 pound six foot two , all lean muscle, self confident and extremely healthy guy. I use the miracle grow concept for growing tomato plants.... if you powerhouse live nutrients into the child while he/she is growing , the end results are a big strong healthy outcome.
-
It is unbelievable, and quite scary, to see some of the commenters on here continuing to regurgitate the weston price foundation anti-soy propaganda that so widely pollutes the internet. You have been duped by a vehemently pro-meat/dairy lobbyist group, the price foundationists are NOT health experts, and all of that anti-soy rhetoric is derived directly from them and their devotees, who have also been duped. That anti-soy book mentioned is written by a biased price foundation devotee, and yes, you can force-feed animals massive amounts of anything and get negative results. The vast majority of their "claims" are hypothesis, not fact, and their "information" is not peer-reviewed. The vast majority of actual legitimate, peer-reviewed research on soyfoods finds them to be extremely beneficial in many ways, and practically every anti-soy claim made by the pricers has been proven completely wrong by legitimate research since. It is highly recommendable NOT to rely on a meat/dairy lobbyist group, or their devotees, for "facts" about vegetarian/vegan foods.
-
Soy and soy products such as tofu and soy milk have been consumed by people in Asia for a long, long time. If you find you react badly to soy, avoid it. But there is no reason to stop eating soy for health reasons if you don't have any sensitivity to it. Use some common sense! And talk to a nutritionist if you have questions. They studied nutrition for years and know much more about benefits and risks of eating or not eating certain foods than anyone on this website seems to. Also, talk to your ob/gyn and a pediatrician if you want help finding unbiased information on nutrition during pregnancy and breastfeeding.
-
I have to say, this was one of the most bizarre posts I've read on this site. I didn't seem balanced at all. I found it very confusing and thought that the information was contradictory if not completely wrong. I'll just pick one-
"Emphasize whole soy foods such as miso, tempeh, tofu, soy milk, and of course the whole soy bean (edamame)"
I want to know how soy milk made it to the list of 'whole soy foods'? It is one of the most highly processed soy foods out there. Do these women really know what they're talking about?
-
I am confused about what Christina means by " soy foods (traditional, again, no isolated soy)". Which foods are considered isolated soy? Tofu? I have successfully switched from soy milk to almond milk but I still like to make a stir-fry with tofu about once a week. Is that OK?
Can anyone recommend a non-biased book or resource about the effects soy has on the body? It seems very trendy among my friends these days to say "I'm gettin' off the soy!" but no one seems to be able to provide a knowledgable answer (with proof) as to WHY... I'm not interested in reading unresearched scare tactics....just some facts! Resources anyone? -
I am disappointed by the information on breastfeeding and sensitivites to soy by Christina, i thought that information was a load of rubbish, pretending soy sensitivities don't exist and if they do it doesn't pass through the breastmilk is laughable!!!
"Even if a baby is shown to be sensitive to soy, nothing seems to come through in the mother's milk, so there is no worry" I dare you to show this to mothers who have babies with soy sensitivities.
Just like the dairy milk industry like to brainwash us into pretending dairy doesn't cause health problems and that dairy is amazing and all of their so called "experts" are actually paid by the dairy industry. It looks like certain Vegans with a passion for soy don't mind doing their own bit of soy promoting with so called "experts". I'm very disapointed in this as it makes us look as silly as the meat and dairy industry when we make downright ridiculous claims but then try and just back it up with "experts".
Silly. -
Some great info here but one big thing that is quite disappointing.
Christina: There is no need to go crazy with protein because you're pregnant. There is protein in everything we eat, except fruit.
There is protein in all wholefoods, including fruit(!!) I consume between 40-60g of protein daily primarily from fruit as a raw vegan (I also consume greens/veg and a small amount of nuts/seeds - a small handful).
-
As a holistic nutritionist I understand that we each have unique nutritional requirements. But the statments in this article are poorly researched and misleading. First, soy protein has been shown widely to have many negative affects on the health. While fermented forms can be beneficial to some people it is important to understand soy is a top allergenic food. I have seen with myself and my clients the harmful symptoms brought on by tofu, soymilk (the two most highly processed forms) and excess soy in general. "The Whole Soy Story" is a book with compelling evidence to back this up. I know women who have used raw cow's milk when breastfeeding was not an option to great success. Their baby's are healthy with strong immune systems. I understand soy can be okay for some to consume but to state there is nothing harmful about it is complete myth.
Respectfully,
Sarah Carlson, NE
-
-

Available at:
Available at:
Join the Discussion!