Have you tried Josie Maran's? I was really impressed with the quality of her cosmetics. Most mascaras irritate my eyes but hers did not. If you live near a Sephora, check it out they're very generous with the samples.
Have you tried Suncoat? I find it very lovely. Very natural in terms of ingredients and the look. I used to love Maybelline and their crazy magical mascaras but I'll take Suncoat any day. You can find it on veganessentials.com, if you want to have a look-see.
Thanks everyone for the suggestions. I have tried Eco Bella and got major smudging. I have not tried the others though and am looking forward to experimenting. It is cool that this forum exists and I can ask a community silly questions like this, go veganism!!
I currently have nvey eco mascara...but i'm almost finished with it-so i want to order a mascara from Jane Iredale Direct--there's a 15% off sale on 1 of the mascaras now. The sale will only be on 4 a few more days. I think 100% pure mascara and Jane Iredale are the best!! I didn't get dramatic lashes from the nvey eco mascara.