Been able to try all except the Wildewood brand. And I'd say the reviews were pretty accurate. I used to buy the Whole Soy brand, but switched over to So Delicious (coconut based) to cut back on my soy intake. Yes, I'd agree it's more pudding-like than yogurt-like (creamy). Another brand I've tried lately is Almond Dream (made from almonds), the label describes 7 different probiotics. It only has 1 gram of protein (the soy ones have more) & doesn't seem too sweet. I actually just use 1/4 to 1/3 of the container to mix up my frozen bluberries, bananas, apple & almonds in the morning.